In December 2019, little did anybody know that the hushed discovery of a novel coronavirus in Wuhan, China would wreak world havoc of an unprecedented scale properly into the next 12 months and past. However what additionally couldn’t have been foreseen was the way in which through which the later named ‘extreme acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 (SARS-CoV-2)’ or ‘COVID-19’ would function such a ruthless exposé of the techniques that underpin in the present day’s globalised society. Amongst myriad different social points, the entrenched financial, cultural, and epistemic buildings of Colonialism’s legacy, similar to examples of up to date racism and labour exploitation, have turn out to be ever clearer with the continued trajectory of this pandemic specifically. In answering the query ‘Do Colonialism and Slavery Really Belong to the Previous?’, this essay makes use of the empirical context of the COVID-19 pandemic and references postpositivist idea to argue that while these practices ought to undoubtedly be relegated to historical past, it’s profoundly evident that colonial logic continues to be endemic within the 2020s, making this a lower than easy process.
You will need to observe that exposing the continued nature of colonial initiatives is all the time an formidable endeavor for quite a few causes – not least as a result of racial points are so widespread and deeply-rooted in a Eurocentric world society similar to our personal, but in addition as a result of revealing the signs of a colonial legacy is inherently private and infrequently painfully affecting by the way in which ‘the trend, sorrow, and despair’ of these ‘whose existence IR has continually displaced and ignored’ (Biswas 2016, p. 229) are examined. Subsequently, it have to be made clear that this piece attracts on “snapshot” proof to determine solely essentially the most pronounced circumstances of racial violence uncovered by the COVID-19 pandemic. By systematically exploring three distinct phenomena – the Sinophobic sentiment of the discourse surrounding COVID-19, the disproportionately excessive COVID-19 danger and demise charges in Black, Asian, and Minority Ethnic (BAME) populations, and the realisation of the implications of racial capitalism on Individuals of Color (POC) throughout a pandemic – it’s supposed that the mere extent to which a lot of colonialism’s ‘buildings and relations of energy are nonetheless in place’ (Abrahamsen 2003, p. 195) is properly illustrated.
The Sinophobic Sentiment of COVID-19 Discourse
It’s turning into more and more clear that the COVID-19 virus has prompted two distinct outbreaks: the primary being the overt risk of lethal illness, however the second being a rising tradition of Sinophobic racism directed at Chinese language nationals and even folks of different Asian descent in Anglo-centric societies. On the time of writing, the American Academy of Pediatrics cited ‘virtually 1900 reviews of discrimination towards Asian Individuals since March 19th, 2020’ (Cheah et al. 2020, p.2). This quantity is probably going an enormous underrepresentation of the true scale of the difficulty. Though the novel coronavirus has straight claimed hundreds of thousands of lives (and counting), this rhetoric of racial discrimination is arguably equally as virulent within the longstanding legacy it leaves and the damaging binaries and hierarchies of energy it centralises. While it could come as a shock to some that these seemingly outmoded reactions of racialised blame and hatred floor at a time the place world togetherness ought to absolutely be promoted, Alexandre White, a historian and medical sociologist argues that it’s little marvel that such a response has arisen given the historic trajectory of ‘xenophobic responses to infectious illness threats’ (2020, p. 1250).
While the concern and panic generated by a pandemic can considerably understandably give rise to irrational reactions from impressionable people, it have to be acknowledged that the racism facilitated on a systemic stage, most notably by the US, the world’s solely dominating superpower, is a really deliberate social assemble. Trump’s inflammatory intentions have been made completely clear upon his labelling of COVID-19 the ‘kung flu’ at a rally in Tulsa, to not point out his earlier coining of the phrase ‘Chinese language virus’ (The Guardian, 21st June 2020). Such discourse is strictly the sort that performs into the longstanding and arguably inevitable pattern of colonial logic, one which Césaire goes so far as evaluating to a ‘boomerang’ (2000, p. 41), and one that may be accounted for by the inextricably linked tenets of Poststructuralism’s power-knowledge nexus. Foucault is obvious in his assertation that the realm of the discursive is one through which identities and regimes of reality are constructed, as is clearly seen with Trump’s anti-Chinese language sentiment. It’s inevitable, nevertheless, Foucault argues, that when a discourse like this pervades, sure knowledges turn out to be ‘subjugated’. That’s to say that individual truths are ‘buried and disguised in a functionalist coherence or formal systematisation’ and can’t be totally insurrected till they exist as ‘historic contents’ (1980, p. 81). On the time of writing, this pandemic exists at current or as very current historical past – and so the discourse of the Chinese language folks (versus that of their authoritarian authorities) is but to be totally realised while it stays wholly quashed by the white individual’s narrative.
This isn’t an remoted prevalence, both. There’s a palpable trickle-down impact because the racial otherisation rooted in official governmental discourse transfers to a media system capitalising on concern and binary displays of nuanced conditions, finally reaching residents who’re motivated to behave violently on their particular person prejudices. This phenomenon has been seen earlier than, most notably in the course of the 2014 Ebola disaster. Sarah Monson writes of how ‘the media triggered Individuals’ concern and conceptualization of Ebola as “different” and “African”, sparking a discourse of panic and propelling the otherization of Africa and Africans’ (2017, p. 3). In the identical approach that Western ‘otherization reproduced and perpetuated the Ebola-is-African, Ebola-is-all-over-Africa, and Africa-is-a-country narratives’ (Monson 2017, p. 3) in 2014, orientalist stigmatisations of China depicted it as a ‘backwards’, ‘horribly overpopulated’ nation whose folks and their ‘archaic’ tradition have been guilty for the COVID-19 outbreak (Borja et al., 2020). It can’t be ignored that historic worldwide administration of infectious illness ‘has largely been formed by a distinctly European perspective, prioritising epidemic threats that arose from colonial (or now post-colonial) websites that threatened to unfold illness and have an effect on commerce’, which has remodeled into an exclusionary and stereotyping ‘Eurocentric or US-centric view’ of contemporary pandemics that does ‘rather more hurt than good’ (White 2020, p.1251). Put merely, the general public discourse surrounding COVID-19 proves that colonialism’s legacy is sadly nonetheless very a lot alive and properly in modern Anglo-centric society, because of basic perception of the ‘white middle-class Westerner’ that the Chinese language are ‘not fairly as human as we’re’ (Saïd 1978, p.108).
Heightened COVID-19 Threat in BAME Populations
Colonialism’s legacy isn’t just affecting the discourse round COVID-19, both: there are pronounced and extremely publicised figures that time in the direction of the disproportionate well being impacts of the virus on folks from BAME teams. Public Well being England data of their ‘Disparities within the Threat and Outcomes of COVID-19’ report that ‘the very best age standardised prognosis charges of COVID-19 per 100,000 inhabitants have been in folks of Black ethnic teams (486 in females and 649 in males) and the bottom have been in folks of White ethnic teams (220 in females and 224 in males)’. Moreover, POC within the UK current with a ten% to 50% larger likelihood of dying from COVID-19 than folks of a White British background ( 2020. p. 39). NHS workers demise charges are notably telling of this pattern: BAME people account for under 44% of medical workers, while roughly 95% of deaths on this workers group by April 2020 have been members of BAME populations (Cook dinner, Kursumovic, and Lennane 2020). Above all else, you will need to observe that that is certainly not on account of any kind of organic predisposition to the virus in sure races. Even Public Well being England is keen to confess in an additional analytical report that ‘the pandemic uncovered and exacerbated longstanding inequalities affecting BAME teams within the UK’ ( 2020, p. 6), as soon as once more bringing into sharp focus the structurally entrenched racial disparities that function on a day-to-day foundation in white-majority society, and that may be traced again to inherently discriminatory colonial logic.
Proof that factors to particular danger components that put folks of BAME communities at elevated danger of buying the an infection makes it blatantly clear that colonial traits are fully internalised throughout the UK’s consciousness (and likely that of different white-majority nations). Typically attributed to the liberal notion of the “class divide”, cited determinants of heightened an infection danger embody the elevated probability of BAME people dwelling in ‘city areas’, ‘overcrowded households’, ‘disadvantaged areas’ and having ‘jobs that expose them to larger danger’ (Public Well being England  2020, p. 40). The issue with this logic, nevertheless, is that it makes the difficulty at hand appear simply fixable, when in actuality, this such “class divide” exists as a hangover from a a lot deeper-rooted mode of perpetual racialised thought that continues to forged POC because the ‘fashionable barbarian’ (Césaire 2000, p. 76).
The identical systemically divisive logic that performed a component in legislative failures similar to Theresa Could’s “Hostile Atmosphere” coverage and the ensuing Windrush scandal, and different extra lethal catastrophes, such because the Grenfell Tower fireplace in 2017, is making a resurgence as soon as extra throughout this pandemic. BAME immigrants to the UK, and certainly the West typically, are seemingly thought-about simply as they have been within the 20th Century: ‘an unlucky however obligatory by-product of sustaining the connection between Britain and the Outdated (white) Dominions’ (El-Enany 2019, p. 52). Behind each Black or Asian individual compelled to operate in a ‘intently interconnected social community[s]’ throughout a lethal pandemic is a legacy that considers their ‘households with prolonged kinship’ as “uncivilised” and thus undeserving of specialized help, and an financial construction that lumbers them with ‘lowered alternative to earn a living from home’ amongst many, many different burdens (Mathur 2020, p. 1866). Subsequently, it’s hardly stunning that the welfare techniques of the West proceed to fail ethnic minorities time and time once more. Non-white populations are persistently handled as an afterthought, relying for survival on techniques that don’t operate with them in thoughts. As soon as once more, the latent existence of colonial practices within the fashionable Western world could be very obvious – and, while there are makes an attempt to resolve the issues exacerbated by this, the ‘mechanisms of energy’ (Foucault 1980, p. 99) that convey these signs about haven’t but been addressed within the obligatory approach required with a purpose to eradicate them fully.
The Implications of Racial Capitalism on POC in the course of the Pandemic
By the identical token, the fashionable capitalist system can’t be ignored for its existence as an inherently and cyclically racist phenomenon that has put BAME populations at explicit danger in the course of the COVID-19 pandemic. Cedric J. Robinson, a black Marxist and founding father of the notion of racial capitalism, asserts that capital ‘can solely accumulate by producing and transferring by way of relations of extreme inequality amongst human teams’ (Melamed 2015, p. 77). It’s greater than clear that ethnicity is without doubt one of the most predominant types of this ‘extreme inequality’ within the 21st Century, that means that the ‘central options of white supremacist capitalist growth’ give rise to ‘slavery, colonialism, genocide, incarceration regimes, migrant exploitation, and modern racial warfare’ (Melamed 2015, p. 77) that notably encumber POC. In different phrases, the exact same colonial logic that perpetuates the idea that the ‘western client’ is ‘entitled to personal or broaden (or each) the vast majority of world sources’ (Saïd 1978, p.108) casts BAME populations to the underside of ladder of neoliberal progress, casting them as victims, moderately than victors, of Capitalism.
The case of London transport employee Stomach Mujinga is a chief instance of the outcomes of the entrenched buildings of Racial Capitalism. In line with The Guardian, the small print surrounding the occasions that in the end led to her demise on the 5th April 2020 are hazy: it’s unclear whether or not the person that spat on her while she was endeavor her duties on the station concourse had really been optimistic for COVID-19, and whether or not it was a direct consequence of his actions that she later examined optimistic herself and died in hospital from problems of the illness (Kale 2020). On this analytical context, nevertheless, these particulars aren’t of explicit relevance. What was delivered to mild within the aftermath of this tragic occasion was the truth that a 47-year-old Congolese mom with underlying respiratory points was put at pointless danger as a frontline employee throughout a pandemic lethal to weak folks like herself. Stomach Mujinga was murdered by a system that disproportionately relegates folks of non-white origin to blue-collar industries after which tells ‘those that nonetheless have low-wage service jobs to put down their lives with a purpose to afford for groceries’ (Boodman 2020).
One other story that made world headlines for comparable causes to the Stomach Mujinga case was that of the Amazon employees on the JFK8 warehouse in New York Metropolis who went on strike after a number of workers examined optimistic for COVID-19. The strikers demanded ‘elevated protecting gear and hazard pay’ throughout the pandemic (Evelyn 2020). This comes after information was launched in 2014 and 2015 that demonstrated that almost 1 / 4 of the corporate’s 77,179-person-strong US workforce was both Black or Hispanic, with a respective 24% and 12% share of Black and Hispanic employees within the ‘labourers and helpers’ class, but solely 5% Black and 5% Hispanic within the ‘non-labourer’ workforce (Greene 2015). It definitely appears that by compelling disproportionate numbers of POC to work in such poor situations throughout a pandemic while the white-majority center lessons ‘keep safely at dwelling with their on-line jobs’ (Boodman 2020), counting on the companies of those multinational firms, the neoliberal capitalist system exerts considerably of the ‘violence, management, and financial exploitation’ (Bales, cited in Manzo 2018, p. 300) frequent to practices of labour exploitation and a few circumstances of contemporary slavery. Certainly, in keeping with Manzo, if all types of ‘violence, management, and financial exploitation are labeled as slavery, then the hundreds of thousands of unlawful and badly-paid migrant employees on the earth essentially belong in that class’ (2018, p. 300-301), highlighting the unnerving and oft hid frequent components shared by capitalism and colonialism.
Not solely are the structural results of ongoing colonial initiatives facilitated by neoliberal Capitalism felt within the Western world, however after all their affect extends globally, difficult the biopolitical notion of the common proper to breathe. Achille Mbembe writes of an ensuing interval of ‘rigidity’ and ‘brutality’ that may come up put up pandemic. The after-effects of COVID-19 will catalyse an ever extra ‘vicious partitioning of the globe’ by the hands of the fashionable division of wealth and sources the place the ‘dividing strains will turn out to be much more entrenched’ (2020). Naturally then, heeding Robinson’s authority, POC worldwide shall undergo most on account of this – not solely will practices similar to ‘energy-intensive extraction, agricultural growth, predatory gross sales of land and destruction of forests’ proceed ‘unabated’, principally concentrating on the ‘International South’ (Mbembe 2020), however the norm of exploiting the “Third World” can be redefined as soon as once more, locking the globe into a brand new period of banishing non-white residents to their ‘jungles’ (Fanon 2008, p. 121).
General, the pronounced stage at which colonial logic operates within the modern context is obvious from this evaluation, even whether it is oftentimes facilitated by covert systemic norms. Regardless of that, calls to completely consign it and its hostile implications to the previous are rising extra insistent: a petition calling for justice for Stomach Mujinga has been signed by over 2 million folks (Kale 2020), and there have been quite a few actions for the reason that demise of George Floyd that demand the structural decolonisation of formally imperialist Western nations through reforming curricula and different social, cultural, and financial phenomena. Others go a step additional and declare that Abolitionism is the one approach ahead – drawing on the black Marxist notion that every one capitalism is racial capitalism, this motion seeks ‘a imaginative and prescient that refers back to the realities uncovered by the pandemic’, aiming to construct ‘a brand new mode of collective care’ that helps ‘mobilization and mutual help’ (Boodman 2020). Both approach, these are each examples of strategies that search to ‘lower off the King’s head’ (Foucault 1980, p. 121) and readdress the present relations of energy, one thing that’s greater than obligatory in a system through which ‘the top of formal colonial rule has not ended historic patterns of financial management and exploitation any greater than the abolition of slavery has eradicated enslavement’ (Manzo 2018, p. 316), whether or not we seek advice from it as a postcolonial or neocolonial society. In the end, neither colonialism nor slavery actually but belong to the previous, even when that’s the present will of ever-larger swathes of society. Will isn’t sufficient with practices so ingrained as these: solely a basic restructuring of society as we all know it’ll convey actually vital change about.
Abrahamsen, Rita (2003) ‘African Research and the Postcolonial Problem’, African Affairs 102 (407), pp. 189– 210.
Biswas, S. (2016) ‘Chapter 12: Postcolonialism’, in Dunne, T., Kurki, M., Smith, S. (ed.) Worldwide Relations Theories: Self-discipline and Range. Oxford: Oxford College Press, pp. 219-233.
Boodman, E. (2020) COVID-19, Biopolitics and Abolitionist Care Past Safety and Containment, Accessible at: https://abolitionjournal.org/covid-19-biopolitics-and-abolitionist-care-beyond-security-and-containment/ (Accessed: twelfth January 2021).
Borja, M., Jeung, R., Horse, A. Y., Gibson, J., Gowing, S., Lin, N., Navins, A., and Energy, E. (2020) Anti-Chinese language Rhetoric Tied to Racism towards Asian Individuals Cease AAPI Hate Report, Accessible at: https://caasf.org/2020/06/anti-chinese-rhetoric-tied-to-racism-against-asian-americans-stop-aapi-hate-report/ (Accessed: tenth January 2021).
Césaire, A. (2000) Discourse on Colonialism, New York: NYU Press.
Cheah, C. S. L., Wang, C., Ren, H., Zong, X., Cho, H. S., and Xue, X. (2020) ‘COVID-19 Racism and Psychological Well being in Chinese language American Households’, Pediatrics, 146(5), pp. 1-10 [Online]. Accessible at: https://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/pediatrics/146/5/e2020021816.full.pdf (Accessed: 10th January 2021).
Cook dinner, T., Kursumovic, E., Lennane, S. (2020) ‘Unique: deaths of NHS workers from covid-19 analysed’, Well being Service Journal, twenty second April. Accessible at: https://www.hsj.co.uk/exclusive-deaths-of-nhs-staff-from-covid-19-analysed/7027471.article#by-ethnicity (Accessed: 11th January 2021).
El-Enany, N. (2019) ‘Earlier than Grenfell: British Immigration Regulation and the Manufacturing of Colonial Areas’, in Bulley, D., Edkins, J., and El-Enany, N. (ed.) After Grenfell: Violence, Resistance and Response. London: Pluto Press, pp. 50-61.
Evelyn (2020) ‘Amazon employees stroll out over lack of protecting gear amid coronavirus’, The Guardian, thirty first March. Accessible at: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/mar/30/amazon-workers-strike-coronavirus (Accessed twelfth January 2021).
Fanon (2008) Black Pores and skin, White Masks, London: Pluto Press.
Foucault, M. (1980) ‘Fact and Energy’, in Foucault, M. and Gordon, C. (ed.) Energy/Data: Chosen Interviews and Different Writings 1972-1977. New York: Pantheon Books, pp. 109-133.
Foucault, M. (1980) ‘Two Lectures’, in Foucault, M. and Gordon, C. (ed.) Energy/Data: Chosen Interviews and Different Writings 1972-1977. New York: Pantheon Books, pp. 78-109.
Greene, J. (2015) ‘Amazon much more various at warehouses than in skilled ranks ‘, The Seattle Occasions, 14th August. Accessible at: https://www.seattletimes.com/business/amazon/amazon-more-diverse-at-its-warehouses-than-among-white-collar-ranks/ (Accessed: 12th January 2021).
Kale (2020) ‘‘I really feel she was deserted’: The life and horrible demise of Stomach Mujinga’, The Guardian, twenty fifth August. Accessible at: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2020/aug/25/i-feel-she-was-abandoned-the-life-and-terrible-death-of-belly-mujinga (Accessed: 12th January 2021).
Manzo, Okay. (2018) ‘Do colonialism and slavery belong to the previous?’, in Edkins, J. and Zehfuss, M. (ed.) International Politics: A New Introduction. London: Routledge, pp. 298-319.
Mathur, R., Bear, L., Khunti, Okay., Eggo, R. M. (2020) ‘Pressing actions and insurance policies wanted to deal with COVID-19 amongst UK ethnic minorities’, The Lancet, 396(10266), pp. 1866-1868.
Mbembe, A. (2020) The Common Proper to Breathe, Accessible at: https://critinq.wordpress.com/2020/04/13/the-universal-right-to-breathe/ (Accessed: twelfth January 2021).
Melamed, J. (2015) ‘Racial Capitalism’, Important Ethnic Research, 1(1), pp. 76-85.
Monson, S. (2017) ‘Ebola as African: American Media Discourses of Panic and Otherization’, Africa At this time, 63(3), pp. 3-27.
Public Well being England  (2020) Past the information: Understanding the affect of COVID-19 on BAME teams, London: PHE Publications.
Public Well being England  (2020) Disparities within the danger and outcomes of COVID-19, London: PHE Publications.
Saïd, E. (1978) Orientalism, London: Penguin.
The Guardian [staff] (2020) ‘Donald Trump calls Covid-19 ‘kung flu’ at Tulsa rally’, The Guardian, twenty first June. Accessible at: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/jun/20/trump-covid-19-kung-flu-racist-language (Accessed: 10th January 2021).
White, A. (2020) ‘Historic linkages: epidemic risk, financial danger, and xenophobia’, The Lancet, 395(10232), pp. 1250-1251.
Written at: The College of Manchester
Written for: Cristina Masters
Date written: January 2021
Additional Studying on E-Worldwide Relations